I Really Tried to be Catholic

I did.

I went back. I could’ve worn the veil – well maybe not. I knelt. I said the Rosary.

I wanted the rhythm, the certainty, the lineage of saints. I wanted the silence of the chapel, the incense, the bones buried beneath altars.

I wanted to belong to something ancient and real.

I longed to believe that faithfulness meant obedience and that obedience would bring me peace.

But my soul would not stay small.

And I could not unknow what I knew.

I wanted the Church to be the harbor—but it became the cage.

I wanted Mary to be my guide—but they had made her so meek I could barely hear her voice.

And so, one morning, I stopped pretending.

Not out of rebellion, but out of reverence for what I could no longer deny:

God was calling me elsewhere.

To the trees.

To the white oak.

To the path that hadn’t been paved in doctrine, but carved in root and stone and sky.

I don’t regret trying.

I needed to see if there was still a home for me there.

There wasn’t.

But there is a grove now.

And I am walking it. More on that later.

Discover more from Temple of Why

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading